Your dashboard can't see where buyers decide

Last week I said most of your buyer's decision happens somewhere you'll never see. A peer recommends you, an AI tool names you, they check your LinkedIn, then they Google you by name and land on your website.

‍

Which raises the awkward question for anyone with a board meeting coming up. If the dashboard can't see most of that, what do you report?

‍

Most scale-up boards I sit with still ask about cost per lead first. I understand why. It's the number they've always had, it's easy to compare quarter on quarter, and after a raise everyone wants proof the money is working. But cost per lead only measures the very last step, and it can make the work that's actually filling your pipeline look like it's doing nothing.

Why the credit goes to the wrong place

Most marketing dashboards give the credit to whatever the buyer clicked last. That's usually the website, a branded Google search or a demo form. All the things that made them type your name in the first place get nothing.

‍

Measurement has also got harder. AI search took off around the same time cookie tracking became much less reliable. So some of the traffic drop teams are worried about is real, and some of it is simply stuff the tools can no longer see.

‍

The risk is a very reasonable-sounding decision in a board meeting: the podcast and the partner content don't show up in attribution, so cut them and put the money into paid search, which does. Six months later paid search gets more expensive, because fewer people are searching your name.

The numbers worth a slot in the board pack

I'd keep it to a handful, each shown as a trend:

‍

• Branded search. How many people search for your company by name each month. If it's rising, something upstream is working, including AI tools recommending you without anyone clicking through
• Share of AI answers. How often you're named when your buyers' questions are put to the AI tools, checked monthly. We run our own tracking for this with clients. The answers change every time you ask, so watch the direction over a few months
• External mentions. How many you've had this quarter against the target your team set
• What buyers tell you. A free-text "How did you hear about us?" on your demo form, plus the same question on the first sales call, tallied every month
• How warm deals arrive. Whether new opportunities turn up already understanding the problem, which shows up as shorter sales cycles and better conversion from first call

‍

None of these is perfect on its own. Together they give the board a picture of whether the market knows you exist, which cost per lead was never going to show. If your team wants a cleaner read on the website numbers too, server-side tracking is worth a look.

How to take it into the room

Start by agreeing that measurement matters, then ask what a closed deal actually costs the business. Most boards can't answer that quickly, and it moves the conversation from leads to revenue.

‍

Then show the buyer journey on one slide, put your handful of numbers next to it, and say what you'll do differently if each one moves. Boards respond to commercial logic. They want to see that someone is making decisions from the numbers, and a list of activity won't show them that.

The one thing to do this week

Ask your team to add a required free-text "How did you hear about us?" field to your demo or contact form, and to ask the same question on every first sales call.

‍

Free text matters here. A drop-down only gives you the options you thought of, and buyers will tell you things like "my old boss mentioned you" or "ChatGPT recommended you" if you leave room for it.

In 6 weeks you'll have a tally to put next to your attribution report. The team owns collecting it. The founder owns turning it into the story for the board.

‍

Drop me a line and tell me which number your board asks about first. I'll tell you honestly how I'd reframe it, including when the answer is that they're asking the right question.

‍

‍PS. Rebuilding the board pack is often one of the first things our fractional CMOs do with a new client, because every other marketing decision gets judged by it. That's the Scale Up model: senior direction and a senior team to deliver it, under one roof. Declared interest. If you'd be better off with someone else, I'll say so.‍