

The hire one founder is holding off on
Last week I asked how much of your marketing you'd hand to a machine. This week the same question kept coming back to me from the other direction, as founders and investors asked who they should actually be hiring.
We've had around 30 calls ahead of the first 1 to 10 Club evening, asking founders and investors what they want to talk about in the room. Team shape and AI come up in almost every one. And the more of these conversations I have, the more I think both questions start in the same place.
The hire he's holding off on
One head of growth, at a £5m business aiming to grow 30 to 40% over the next 12 to 18 months, told us he's deliberately holding off on his next marketing hire. His hunch is that the skills he'll need in 6 months will look quite different from the ones he'd hire for today. So for now he's covering a lot of it himself, from marketing ops and creative to the website, alongside one SDR.
I think he's right to wait.
Waiting works best when you know what you're waiting to find out, and he does.
What we're seeing in our own team
His hunch matches what we're seeing in our own team.
Paul spends most of his week building things: lead gen tools, landing pages, ad tests across ChatGPT and Reddit. He has a fairly generic title of growth manager, mainly because we haven't found a better name for it yet - skills needed before a job title is agreed.
The test I wrote about last week is changing how we work too. For the next group, every interview transcript goes into the system first, so it can build the first draft of each person's content from what they actually said. Then we'll bring in the AI interviewer, with our strategist stepping in for anyone whose results come back thin.
What we've found so far is mostly about timing. The first group were interviewed before some of them had settled what they wanted to be known for, and you could feel the panic. So next time the interview comes later, and anyone who already knows their topic can go first.
We also found that 30 minutes doesn't suit everyone. One interview ran to an hour because he simply had more to say. That might turn out to be a quiet advantage of an AI interviewer, which has no slot to fill and no next call to get to.
That's the kind of thing you only find out by doing it, which is exactly what our head of growth is waiting for.
After the compliments
Doing it also means being honest about what counts as working. The first group's content kits went out last week and the feedback was lovely. I've been doing this long enough to know a kit everyone loves can still sit untouched in a folder.
So at the next workshop on 18 November we've set one goal. By the end of the hour, every person in the room will have sent at least one outreach message to a podcast or event on their list, with drafts ready for anyone who wants a head start. That first message is the one that turns into a habit.
Left or right
Which brings me to the most useful thing anyone said to me this week. An experienced chair we spoke to, who's spent years helping venture-backed businesses through difficult patches, said something about boards that I think applies to marketing teams too.
Most board arguments are about whether to turn left or right, when the board hasn't agreed where the business is or where it's realistically heading. His first step is to get everyone to let go of the plan they invested in, and agree where the business actually is today.
I've watched the same thing happen with team shape. A board asks whether you should hire a head of content or buy another tool, and the conversation goes round in circles because the room hasn't aligned what the team is there to achieve over the next year.
Where I've landed, for now
So I'd put last week's question and this week's together.
Before you decide which parts of marketing a machine can take on, and before you decide who to hire, agree what the team is there to achieve over the next 12 months. Then work out which of those jobs need someone's judgement, and which just need doing quickly and well.
The people I'd hold on to hardest are the ones who know how to ask the follow-up question. Most of the rest is getting easier to build.
The one thing to do this week
Before your next hiring conversation, ask your marketing lead to write down the outcomes the team owns over the next 12 months, and next to each one, the work that gets it there. Then go through it together and mark each piece: does this need a person's judgement, or could it be built or automated?
The pieces your team can't agree on are where the conversation about the next hire, or the next tool, should start.
Drop me a line and tell me what you find. And if you replied to last week's issue, thank you, love these conversations.
All of our knowledge,
in one weekly email
Join 2700+ scaling businesses tapping into our marketing knowledge on everything you need to scale up your growth and marketing efforts.